Article: What It Really Takes to Build a Different Cotton Sourcing Model

What It Really Takes to Build a Different Cotton Sourcing Model
A collaboration between Cotton Diaries and DAWN
In fashion, stories often only emerge once they are neat and tidy.
A partnership is announced once the project is complete. Or a new approach only becomes visible once all the friction points have been smoothed over and a polished marketing campaign is ready.
This series is not really about that kind of storytelling.
What DAWN Denim and Cotton Diaries want to document is something less polished, but more useful. It helps to understand what brands actually go through before the neatly packaged story is created – and at the same time gives the industry something to learn from. At its core, it is about what it really looks like to build a different cotton sourcing model in real time – including the coordination, the complications, and the points where both sides had to adjust their expectations and keep going without a ready-made formula.
That is part of the reason why this collaboration made sense from the beginning.
Behind the collaboration
Why did this collaboration make sense for both sides?
This collaboration made sense because it brought together different kinds of proximity to the problem. Cotton Diaries brought a systemic perspective, expertise, sourcing questions, and a broader network of potential partners and pathways. DAWN brought operational proximity, insight into its own manufacturing, and a supply network where ideas could be tested to see if they would hold up in practice. This combination made it possible to connect a longer-term vision with the realities of implementation.
How did the collaboration between DAWN and Cotton Diaries come about?
DAWN and Cotton Diaries came together because we – from different positions in the textile industry – were already asking some of the same questions: How can we move cotton sourcing beyond a purely transactional model, where cotton is treated primarily as a material to be purchased – instead of something shaped by people, places, and growing conditions? What would be needed to build relationships that are more resilient and more deeply rooted in genuine connection? And what structures need to exist if the goal is not just to buy cotton with a better claim – such as GOTS-certified organic cotton –, but to improve livelihoods, especially those of the farmers?
This shared thinking made the collaboration feel completely natural from the start. It was never just about finding a different cotton input. It was about the broader interest in building a more strongly networked sourcing network and moving away from the usual logic of procurement towards regeneration.
Regenerative agriculture is a holistic, place-based, results-oriented, and systemic approach to agriculture that works in harmony with natural ecosystems and places the resilience and interconnectedness of the environment and human communities at its center. Rooted in indigenous practices, it emphasizes ecological health, social justice, and place-based solutions – rather than a one-size-fits-all checklist for everyone.
Regenerative agriculture honors practices that restore and strengthen ecosystems, while also recognizing that certified organic farming methods can provide a strong foundation for further regenerative efforts.
What foundation did DAWN already have in its own supply chain?
For a project like this, DAWN did not start from scratch. Unlike many small brands, DAWN already had its own manufacturing in Vietnam – the factory that cuts and sews the jeans was therefore part of the picture from the start. This is unusual, because this is often where visibility ends in the value chain. DAWN also had a close relationship with its spinning and weaving partner – the part of the supply chain that transforms fibers into yarn and fabric. This was crucial because the people who make a finished product from cotton were already close enough to test whether a new approach could actually hold up. So a large part of the structure was already in place – what was still missing was the cotton source itself, as well as the right upstream partners and the right expertise.
EVOLUTION LAB SAIGON in Saigon, Vietnam
SAITEXX Mill in Saigon, Vietnam
What did DAWN learn from trying to trace cotton backward?
Before Cotton Diaries joined, DAWN had already begun exploring other sourcing routes – including Tanzania. This earlier path is important because it revealed how quickly complexity comes to the surface as soon as a brand engages more directly with cotton.
For DAWN founder Marian von Rappard, it was not his first attempt to understand where their cotton might come from or what a different cotton pathway could look like. As early as 2018, DAWN had tried to work backward through the existing supply chain to find a more direct way back to the farmers who grew the cotton for their jeans. But this approach quickly reached its limits.
“In 2018, we tried it top-down … we looked in our existing supply chain to trace the path back to the cotton farmers. It failed. The chain was too long, too opaque – and we were too small to bend it from our end.”
This failure became an important lesson. If tracing backward through an already complex supply chain does not work, then the logic has to change. Instead of starting with the finished supply chain and searching for the farm behind it, DAWN had to start with the right partner and the right relationship – and work forward from there.
“Instead of starting from our supply chain and hunting backward for a farm, we start from the right farming community and the right partner – and then nominate them into our supply chain.”
In many ways, this shift in perspective says a lot about why this project is important. Marian did not try to simplify cotton into a clean story. He traveled, asked questions, and looked for possible routes in places like Tanzania – and in doing so, he also discovered how much more he still had to learn. From the outside, cotton can seem simple, but behind a single sourcing decision are fiber qualities, spinning mill requirements, realities at the farm level, certification systems, pricing questions, geography, climate, and the operational needs of every individual partner in the chain.
This is not a criticism – it is part of the story. Just as most people do not know that the cotton in a garment labeled “Made in Italy” can come from a completely different part of the world. In the same way, even brands that want to do better can underestimate how much the finished fabric has become decoupled from the raw material where it all begins.
If this shows one thing, it is how easy it is to underestimate cotton – and that cotton is not a topic that most brands can or should tackle alone.
Cotton quality explained
What did the Tanzania route show about cotton quality?
The closer DAWN looked, the clearer it became: A promising route must still hold up across all partners in the value chain. It initially looked promising, but lost relevance as soon as it had to work within the broader supply network. The fiber quality did not meet the standards of DAWN’s spinning mill partner, so the path could not continue. For the project to have a real chance, DAWN needed its spinning mill partner on board: partly because they would transform the fiber into usable material, and partly because the quantities had to fit their spinning mill setup. If these conditions do not come together, a route can quickly become unusable – even if the original ambition is strong.
Why do small fashion brands need partners to build better sourcing models?
This is one of the reasons why such projects can feel difficult for smaller brands.
There are simply too many moving parts for most small and medium-sized brands to handle alone. Even if the intention is strong, they may lack the structure. They may lack leverage – enough influence, size, or purchasing power to shape decisions further up the chain or get a real seat at the table. A small brand may only need a small amount of cotton, while a spinning mill needs enough volume to keep the machines running, and a trader needs enough to fill a container. Even “medium-sized” can mean very different things in practice. One brand may only need a small run of 100, another 1,000 more – and both may still be below the scale at which an upstream player is willing to adapt, invest, or prioritize the project. This imbalance can make even a well-intentioned project difficult to sustain.
Capacity also plays a role. DAWN’s sustainability team consists of one person – and this is not the only project on their plate. This means: momentum can stall – not because the ambition disappears, but because the work has to compete with other priorities and limited internal bandwidth.
Collaboration is important because it helps distribute some of this weight and build the scale the project may need. But this is not a one-sided dependency. Small brands often need larger partners to multiply their impact. Larger partners, in turn, often need smaller brands to test things out faster, act more agilely, and take the early risks that are harder to bear in larger corporate structures.
Why partnerships matter
Why do larger partners also need small brands?
Small and medium-sized brands are often expected to innovate as if good intentions alone were enough. In practice, many lack the leverage (which determines the balance of power), the volume, the financial resources, the internal capacity, or the direct access to build more relationship-based sourcing models alone that have a tangible impact.
Smaller brands can often act faster, test earlier, and take creative risks. Larger partners bring scale, infrastructure, technical depth, and the ability to multiply impact beyond a single pilot project or product. At the same time, they depend on brands for feedback from the market – on needs, desires, and regulatory requirements.
The point is not that one side is more important than the other – but that both fill different gaps.
What did Cotton Diaries and DAWN each bring to the project?
Cotton Diaries comes into play here as well.
We did not enter the process with a finished answer. Cotton Diaries brought a broader systemic perspective, a larger network, and the commitment to frame the project beyond a narrowly defined sourcing conversation. DAWN brought the operational reality, the internal processes, and the constant reminder that the work must make sense not only in theory, but also in sourcing, product development, and daily decision-making.
This exchange did not always go smoothly – but that was exactly part of the point. While Cotton Diaries pushed to keep the project connected to the larger systemic questions, DAWN pushed to ensure that these ideas could withstand the actual realities of production – and this tension grounded the work.
Why are early setbacks part of building a new sourcing model?
The Tanzania route was not the only setback. Even after this early lesson, new friction points continued to emerge. Quality concerns arose again with other potential partners. Availability was not always straightforward. And as with many small brands, this is not the only project on the plate.
This is part of what makes such projects so difficult to explain from the outside. The challenge is not always one dramatic failure. More often, it is a series of smaller realities that repeatedly test whether the structure around the project is strong enough to hold up.
This does not automatically mean that the ambition was wrong – it means that the project finally hit reality.
That is why the first hurdle should not be treated as the end of the journey. Early setbacks are not necessarily a sign of failure. When a project requires people to leave familiar ways of working, some friction is to be expected. Often, it shows exactly where stronger coordination, clearer roles, or a more realistic structure are still needed.
What this series really wants to offer
This phase of the project does not yet involve a direct partnership with cotton farmers – and it is important to state that clearly. But over time, this documentation is intended to open up and include more of the people who shape cotton at its earliest stages. For now, this collaboration offers a glimpse of what it looks like to keep working when things get more complicated than expected.
“We would rather be caught trying than pretending.”
In the coming months, the series will continue to document this process – from the question of how we defined “regenerative” together with DAWN and approached partner selection, through the lessons around fiber testing and technical validation, to the question of why a project can look right on paper and still not hold up in practice. The hope is that this will be useful not only for DAWN and Cotton Diaries, but for everyone navigating the same questions – with more honesty, more clarity, and stronger relationships across the entire supply network.








